Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream

I don’t want to be mean but I do want to be honest. I did not enjoy eating this pizza. Dough was thin, floppy and perhaps undercooked. Sauce was weird, cheese was bland and even the pepperoni didn’t taste right. I’ve had better frozen pizzas. Another reviewer on here scored this in the eights and, while that is absolutely insane, the pizza he had did look much better than the one I got. Maybe they just went downhill in the last few years? Who knows. They do have good ice cream though.

This is a poor imitation of pizza. Crust claims to be hand tossed but looks and tastes like a preformed disk. Sauce tastes like spaghetti sauce. Greasy cheese.

Loved the pizza can’t wait to come back