Primo's Pizza

First time trying New Windsor pizza. And it was really good! We also ordered the garlic bread with cheese to share and it was also very tasty! Both the pizza and garlic were solid as hell! We’ll definitely come back there again! Garlic bread with cheese: 8.4 Michael’s rating: 8.2 Garlic bread with cheese: 8.4

It’s a decent slice. A little greasy and lack of flavor. Not saying it’s bad. It’s average slice is very large so you get a good size slice. Halfway decent undercarriage 7.1.

The pizza had a weak undercarriage. Definitely needs an extra few minutes in the oven. Don’t rush the process. The meat balls were gas. The calzone was also cooked a bit fast. And the delivery boy didn’t want my pre rolls so that was a first. I would come here again but it never will be my first choice.

Now, its not a Friday, but i had to drive to Newburgh for my car lease end. So why not grab a slice and review. Massive slices! A tad bit of flop. Little grease. But overall very good. Not in the 8’s, but close. Maybe on another day. Sauce is good. Sweet. Crunchy crust. Thin.

Great pizza as always. Crust is always incredible, sauce has amazing taste, as well with the cheese and toppings. Great ratio between sauce-cheese. Deserves a 8

Little flop, great crunch to the crust, good looking bottom end.

Amazing tangy sauce, right amount of cheese and little to no flop on this beauty. I’ve had mid-7s in here before (which is respectable) but tonight was great.

No flop Greasy as hell, cheese terrible, sauce tastes cheap and so does the dough. The chick behind the counter was 😍.

Not bad. Greasy. Little flop. Good for football. Of it was fresh out the oven it would be a soupy mess.

Decent slice and pretty big. I like the sauce on this one and there was very little grease.

Good crust,good smell, sauce and cheese had nice taste.

Not bad, little dry, huge fuckin slice