Prince Street Pizza

A re-score of one of my favorite spots. You can never go wrong the pep square from Prince St. Overall a fantastic slice. Slight point deduction for actually being overcooked and turning some areas of crust into char.

Great slice, excellent crisp and tangy sauce.

Square slices don't get any better than this. This sets the bar

As cliche as it is, this is the best slice of pizza I’ve had in New York

Review is on my first and only slice of New York pizza so my review might be skewed. One of my reasons for traveling to New York was to enjoy a slice of pizza and this place was recommended. I was not disappointed. Awesome compared to my home town. If every pizza place is as good as this place, I need to move, lol. Thanks El Pres !!

Good pizza

Had to try it! This one was disappointing! Adriennes Pizza Bar has a similar style pizza that Dave gave a low score to and Prince St is not even close to that one. I think Adrienne’s is much much better! Definitely not worth the wait!

this pepperoni square slice was very tasty and had good crunch for a thicker slice. the pizza was slightly on the greasy side but to be expected with the large amount of crispy delish pepps. very nice square pepp pizza for a NY lunch

Man the square slice was freaking fantastic this was my first new york pizza slice and I hate to say but its much better than CA.

Above Average slice of pizza. A bit overhyped and crowded this piece could have been a lot crispier and didn’t feel the love from the people working there. Still good just not worth the hype around it.

Vodka sauce pizza was really good, but the pepperoni was even better and I’m not a huge pepperoni fan at all!

Mediocre pizza at best, soggy bottom sauce too sweet

Very Doughy, Sauce was incredibly sweet for my liking.

The spicy pepperoni was on another level! One of the best New York has to offer!

Good crisp, tasty sauce, slight flop on the end. Overall, a very good slice.

Spicy pepperoni square slice is a true 9.0. One of the best slices in NY. The cheese slice was a solid 8.6 but definitely get the square. This and Luigi’s are the best 2 in NYC

Crunchy n crispy crust, semi sweet sauce almost creamy, perfect cheese ratio. Don’t know how you can make a better pizza