Red Tomato Pizzeria

fave pizza in Madison

For all you New York / New Jersey pizza snobs like me if you are in visiting the shoreline (remember to go home 😐) this is the best pizza. Better than Grand Appiza. Decent undercarriage not too much flop, crispy and good flavor. Hole in the wall on route 1 you will find it with all the New York license plates out front.

7.5 for cheese.

Good sauce on pizza, too much grease

Real Good! Tangy sweet sauce, crispy crust and good cheese! This place is the best pizza on the shoreline! I hope el prez gives this place a try. The Red Tomato is a CT top 10, no question.

Alright Frankie, Red Tomato, Madison-Guilford town line. Probably the best pizza you’re gonna get outside of New Haven. Thin crispy crust, quality sauce with a bit of zing to it. A bit too much flop for my liking, but a good pie nonetheless. (Pro tip: Salt the crust a bit by rubbing it in on your plate, helps to bring out the flavor.)

Cheese/sauce was decent, crust was burnt and not great flavor. Average slice nothing special