Renna's Pizza

The taste was great, the crust was floppy in the front, crunchy in the back, it was good but the flop, and grease are what killed it!

Looks deceived me i cant lie hopes we’re low especially when I saw this layer of grease as a protective coating on top. However the flavor was actually great. A lot of flop on it, also one of the thinnest I’ve ever ate. Crust tanked the score at the end

Taste was there, cheese was there, sauce and crust was not. The crust was um maybe not the best but I enjoyed the taste, overall idk if i’d come back as it’s a closing mall but not awful.

Man this slice had very good flavor, but was an absolute grease ball. Could probably wring this thing out like a towel and fill a bath tub. Was really impressed with this pizza till I got to the crust, then it brought the score down. Promising but lights were too bright in the fourth quarter.

Solid Slice in Olean. Not as great as it used to be. But phenomenal still

Order by the slice for a crispier bite

Rookie Score! If this thing was cooked a little longer, and it didnt have a shit ton on cheese, it’d be really good! The sauce was great, the cheese was good too, not greasy, but too much of it. Crust wasn’t terrible but seemed awfully heavy and rubbery for it being as thin as it is. Nice try Renna’s id eat it again.

Thin crust, saucy, cheese was on point.

One bite everybody knows the rules

One of the best around

Not bad, this place is a staple in the community. Little greasy and runny, no flop, decent crust. Sauce is very good.

thin, crispy. must be heated up. 6.9. that’s a review

big new york flop. on the greasier side. lot of crunch in the crust. up at the top of what olean has to offer