Rosario's Trattoria & Pizzeria

Tried based on high reviews, I cannot say I’m a fan. It was bland, undercooked, needed salt, texture of the cheese was odd. It just tasted stale or we got a pie that was sitting out or someone’s order that wasn’t picked up. I wouldn’t suggest to a friend, but try it for yourself and you be the judge.

Sitting slice but excellent very well balanced damn. Maybe a whole pie wouldve gotten it into the 8’s

Great balance between cheese and sauce. Thin with nice undercarriage.

Unique Sicilian

The cheese makes this Pie. The sauce is excellent. Undercarriage was good. A lot of flop and the middle was messy. The crust was dry and hard.

Brooklyn style is awesome!

I got both slices but I am reviewing the gold standard. I felt that the score could’ve been a little higher but my slice was a little messy in the middle and fell apart. Good crisp on the outer crust lots of flop in the middle. Sauce is decent, but the cheese was phenomenal. Looks like a nice place to have dinner, not just pizza.

Brooklyn style Sicilian is where it’s at here. Standard pie is like a 7.1