Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant

The sauce and overall flavor was the star of this show. You could tell that only fresh ingredients are used. However, the slice had no crisp, but wasn’t doughy either. It really kept the score in the average LI slice range, and not in the higher range, which for a slice of this flavor profile deserves.

I will start by saying I love the layout of place and will be back to try other items. The selection options were strong and overall set up was intriguing. The pizza pictured was solid as a standalone

Tasty slice. Little flop. I wanted a little more sauce. This spot has been a local favorite for decades.

Slice was super fresh. The sauce was fantastic. Nice undercarriage and a thin crust up top is really good. Cheese was fresh as well. A little heavy on the sauce to cheese ratio. There was heavy pockets of sauce with no cheese and then all cheese and no sauce. Only thing bringing this slice down for me. Still overall a really good slice and would definitely recommend and come back in the future.

Scored the regular. This juuuuust gets in the 7’s for me… amateur score? Ay oh, I think not ~ it is what it is. Just your average football pie. No crunch, lil heavy on the cheese. Still, it’s pizza. And pizza is good. Little riceballs ~ cute idea. Looks even more tedious to make them that size. And they have peas in them. No Bueno for me. Nooooo peas in riceballs. Mama Marine says no.

Sorry for the half eaten slice. I wasn’t gonna review since it wasn’t a full pie. Ton of sweet tomato sauce crust was a little puffy but not overly detrimental. Cheese was gooey but not overly flavorful. Sauce 9 and great quantity Cheese 7 Crust 7

I would come here again, thw sauce was very..and I mean very fresh. The cheese was just as good if not better and they both complimented each other very well. The only negative I had was that it was a little burnt in places. This isn't fair for the rating being that it most likely isn't always burnt so I will not count it.

Crunchy crust, tasty sauce, no grease… good slice! 🍕

Good Pizza! Even amount of good tasting sauce and cheese.

Very solid. Good sauce and great service.

Tangy sauce and very flavorful. Nothing to go out of your way for but very reliable hometown pizza.

No Flop, Great Crunchy Crust, No Grease, Best Pizza in Town by far...Highly Recommend!

Great overall slice, very good sauce with the perfect amount of cheese. No flop to it at all