Rotolo's Pizza

Best pizza in Columbus! Always consistent. Rotolo family has been killing it for years. Excellent customer service and pizzas that are the best of the best. Perfect texture on the crust. Give them a try!

It has so much potential as a great spot. But when the pie tastes better after you put it back in the oven at 420 for 8 minutes that’s an issue. They should look into doing a Nona Pie because the crust would be great for it.

Absolutely electric. Sauce is outstanding, cheese is heavy and flavorful

Not a fan of the square cut. Zero flop, decent undercarriage. Cheese slides off with first bite. Sauce had a sweetness to it that was great.

Best sauce in Columbus imo. Cheese was okay. Not much of a crisp. Solid pie.

Very average