Sal's Pizzeria

Great crisp to the cheese. Not too thin, great flavor.

Meh. Subpar truthfully. Ate a regular slice too and didn’t feel any differently. Classic and Sicilian are both made with your run of the mill pizzeria cheese. Pepperonis are the store bought variety based on how thin they are and how they don’t cup up when cooked. Sauce is good though. And they made it well done how I liked it. If you’re a local it’s fine. Better than Romanos. I would suggest trying Rascos though in Edgewater over this.

Destination spot for me. Drove 3miles in 25 min. Translation ? Traffic didn't dissuade me. I remember it was worth it.

Large pie, ask for well done! Good consistency, good bread to sauce to cheese ratio. As a kid I loved this place , as an adult living in boring S. jersey absolutely miss this place- does not disappoint. Dave bring yourself here he’d give it a solid 8-8.5!

Good solid tasty slice!!

The pizza had a really good flavor. However it lacked quite a few things. Wasn’t crispy at all, it was very dense and heavy, asking for it well done it came out to be a standard bake at best. With a thinner crust and cooking it to the customers liking this pizza could be in the upper 7’s easily

Good flavor. Undercooked and doughy. But very good.

Crispy, old school WNY/North Bergen.

I’ve been reading some of these reviews smh people must just love to talk just to talk... Great Slice 7.5

Thin, crispy, sauce is unreal! Out of this world!

Solid pizza

Best pizza in area that I have tried. Good sauce and cheese balance. Not floppy crust.

Decent pizza

Some Flop going on. The sauce was on the tangy side, the oil level was heavy and the crust was semi-crispy. A tasty slice!

I've been living in NJ for the past 10 years, this is nearest I've had to NY pizza. Definitely up there in hudson county. Ralph's however in Nutley is way better!!!

Absolutely love it. This is good pizza the crust is nearly perfect (the dough is astounding) the cheese has an old style flavor to it and the sauce has a great tangy original marinara taste to it.

Has zero flop, perfect crisp, good sauce, good cheese. The kind of slice you’d crave at night. It’s amazing. Best pizza around no doubt

Good football pizza.....major flop good cheese nothing go out of your way

Ordered the medium. Little too doughy for my taste. Sauce is good tho. 6.9, if i ordered a slice from the counter instead of delivery, probably better

Aesthetically this pizza looks average, but looks can be deceiving sometimes. This was a strong slice that checked off all the boxes. Place has been around for quite some time and they know how to make a good pizza. These were two reheated slices I picked up for lunch, but if I ordered a fresh pie I could see myself scoring into the mid 8's.

It is a home run. Delicious on all levels. Wow.

Crust is great. Too much cheese compared to the amount of sauce.