My friends all tell me that Sal’s is the best pizza in the Dirty J so I had to give it a try. Pizza is super cheesy which causes it to be super greasy and floppy. All of the cheese tastes good, but I would definitely prefer less so it wasn’t as greasy. Finally got a good taste for the sauce as I got to the end of the crust. The sauce tastes really good, but you can’t taste it because of all the cheese. If they distributed more sauce throughout the entire pie instead of just at the end by the crust the score would be much higher.
pizzabelly521/24/22, 2:06 p.m.
Lots of grease and cheese in this pie. Could of used a minute or 2 more in the oven IMO. Sauce was unforgettable and overpowered by the cheese
pizzalover69222/27/21, 9:51 p.m.
Good football pizza. Tangy sauce with pretty decent cheese coverage. Could and will eat all of it. A little doughy for me but over 7.4. That’s a review.
stoolpresidentepgh3/28/20, 8:11 p.m.
7.2 pretty good. Little too much cheese. Underrated spot in town. Good neighborhood pie
timothy.mccreary1/29/20, 2:11 a.m.
Best pizza in Johnstown, Pa little greasy but Sal is a straight Italian guy always too quality pizza from a great guy. Not sure when he was established but he's been here a good while! Hope one day we can have your presence here prez!
chris.laughman7/6/19, 3:36 p.m.
Felt like an El Pres review- straight outta the oven, nice couple manning the shop, solid Johnstown flop, football pizza.
imakepizzasoiknowmyshit2/28/19, 7:19 p.m.
Get the pizza made fresh for slices! Pound for pound it’s the best in the area! “When it’s on”