Santino's Little Italy

Here’s what’s left of a Paisano and a Margherita. Very good pie with great undercarriage. Staff very friendly and a nice quiet place. Highly recommend!

8th Annual Pizza Review Results Group Average of 21 Attendees: Took 7th Place Out of 8 Total Stops

Best pizza I’ve had in Wisconsin.

How u say “tits” in Italian?! If u like Neo style get your rod in here and get some bocci meatballs

Coal fire? Not crisp, but ingredients are top notch

I had the Capriccosa. Crust had lots of flop but the perfect texture. Toppings were fresh and delicious. Definitely a top pizza place in the Milwaukee area.

Margharita pizza, lot of sauce and everything slides off but it tastes amazing

I have tried almost all the best pizza places in Milwaukee. This is my first 9. Excellent all around. Highly recommend it.

Good ingredients. Very floppy

A pie that will make-love to your stomach...

Great Neapolotin style pizza. Crust is crispy and airy with good undercarriage. Sauce has perfect tang, ingredients are high quality 🍕

This pizza is fire! The Bocce Ball, which is a monster meatball covered in red sauce and cheese, is decadent! The service is outstanding, and Santino and Greg, the owners, make you feel like you are family! A must try experience in Milwaukee for sure! Don’t forget to order dessert.

The look of this pizza was great. It really has that authentic, fire cooked feel to it. The taste really feel flat for me. The crust didn't have much flavor and was too chewy. The sauce and cheese were just okay.

It was truly amazing.

The crust on this pizza is amazing. My personal favorite pie is the chicken & potato pizza but every slice here is great

Cheese - Sausage - Pepperoni The flavors are AMAZING!!

So much of daddy’s special sauce

Really good pie great crust

Probably top 3-4 pizzas in Milwaukee. They use authentic ingredients and it shows. The crust is crispy and the thin body is still a touch soft. Such a good pizza