Scarr's Pizza

Listen, it is not worth waiting an hour for a slice from this place. There are far better spots like Patsy's or Luigi's. The Sicilian slice was served burnt, and the 2 regular slices were good but not outstanding. If there's a line when you get there, just keep going.

Crispy. Perfect sauce.

Good but not worth waiting 35 minutes in line for.

Good all around pie. Definitely stop in if you’re in the area

The crisp on this pizza is everything you’d want. Every bite has a crisp, the crust gives way to a soft, delicious dough. Worth checking out!

Great sauce, good undercarriage and bite, wish the cheese had a bit more flavour, but very very good

It's the quintessential Manhattan slice. Sure the vibes are immaculate but at the end of the day the pizza steals the show. The HotBoi slice is one of the best meals I've ever had. (Photo cred to Scarr’s)

Great slice, staff was quick. I dont know if id wait in a line up the street tho, but seems like the best in the area. Same conclusion as prez for me

New #1 Pizza. Perfect undercarriage and crust, the sauce subtle, tomatoey, and slightly sweet. I mean this will prolly be my 1st place for a while

As good as a slice shop can get. Line is absolutely worth waiting in. Flavors were fan fucking tastic. Undercarriage was unreal. Regular > cheese over the marg though

Middle of the road for me. Solid slice but I wouldn’t wait more than 10 mins for this slice. Heavy on the cheese which had a strong flavor. Good vibe inside though

Wanted this to be elite, but alas - looked better than it tasted. With prez that this isn’t an 8

Pepperoni slice with mikes hot honey

Dave needs to review Scarr’s again. The slices I had were vastly different than his. These were light, crispy, chewy, and super flavorful.

Solid slice! Love that there isn’t too much sauce. Excellent pepperoni. Great environment

Great score, but I had higher hopes for this given all the hype. I respect the work that goes into it, but I just wasn’t blown away. Greasy, chewy, tomatoey, salty. Great option if you’re in the city, maybe not worth a special trip though.

Solid slice but doesn’t stand out

One long wait to get in the door. Super crunch. Really good pie but the wait was crazy!