Sexton’s Pizza

know you're in a frat, but what made you think it'd be alright to wear a Miller Lite® sweat band to church with my family?

I didn’t enjoy the flavor and it was a bit dry and overcooked for my liking, but I know some people love it this way. It is all about preference so you may like it better.

Crispy crust. Good flavor, a little chewy.

Great Crisp, tasted fresh, even after driving home it tasted like it just came out of the oven!

👌🏻

Very chewy crust, tastes like the oven. The sauce is lacking. However, the cheese and pepperoni were good. I wouldn’t come back.

Great pizza. Very easy too eat. Crust is thinner than Dave’s review. The dough is a tad chewy but overall a place I would recommend. The Bar/restaurant has a great atmosphere as well.

Cooked to a crispy perfection.

crisp could use some more sauce but great pizza

amazing pizza dave wasn’t wrong

Dave got this right with an 8.1. Amazing crunch!! Cooked perfectly with a great undercarriage and very crispy. I love the sauce on it too. Just was a little greasy.

Outstanding Crunch. A legit 8.1

Perfect balance of thin and light but a ton of flavor. The crust is crunchy and has a nice char taste that gives the flavor of the sauce and toppings that’s extra edge. Best I’ve had in Columbus by far

This was my first time eating this type of pizza. The pizza itself tastes decent but the crust is thick and way too crunchy for my liking. The staff were very kind but the store has no phone number to call. 6.5 is my score.

Not messy. Good crunch. Great crust. Just not anything special. Not enough sauce

Good crust

amazing za

One of the best slices in Columbus… they need to figure out how to function their TVs though

Some of the best if not the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus. If all I knew was Central Ohio pizza this would be in the 9’s.

Definitely phenomenal pizza, me personally I’m a cheese lover and I would have liked to have just a little more cheese. Overall very satisfied and the crust was crispy yet soft in the middle.

Lots of crunch, light and crispy. Toppings could be more consistent…best pep and cheese in town.