Sexton's Pizza

New to Columbus and already my favorite pizza here. Tried several and Sexton's is far and away #1. Bonus:. Excellent customer service. Thanks Joey!!!

Sexton’s Pizza, Reynoldsburg location. Extremely impressed with the dough and sauce, like EXTREMELY impressed. Also the cook of the dough was perfect. If the cheese and particularly the pepperonis were cooked better this could’ve been something special. As it is, the ezzo cup and char’s are barely cupped. I basically always order my pizza well done if I’m getting pepperoni on it but I ordered this online and it didn’t have the well done option. I almost called to add it but didn’t. Now I’m kicking myself. Also the side of hot honey was incredible. Delicious but very hot. I like the heat but I could see it being too hot for a lot of people. Ugh this is tough because I feel like if I just would’ve asked for well done we could be in the mid-high 8’s. But maybe to get the top well done the dough wouldn’t be as perfect as this was. Because of that, I can’t get into the 8s but I’ll go next best thing, 7.9. I’ll definitely go back and request it well done and see if it’s something special.

High quality ingredients, good crust. Average sauce. The Detroit style is very good too- maybe a 7.6 score‼️

Quality pie, good fresh ingredients, solid crust. Also had the Detroit style with hot honey and it was an 8.4

Crust is CRISPY with good char. Good amount of toppings just missing that “something” decent pizza

Very crispy, great amount of old school pepps, and little char. Would have been amazing hot!

Liked crispy crust and cheese

Little greasy and a tad burnt but decent

This is great pizza. Sauce is both salty and sweet, unique taste. Definitely good pizza.

Alright Frankie, good pizza, good service and good atmosphere.

Alright Frankie, the crust is crispy, sauce is just right and the cheese is unbelievable. 8.3! So far best pizza in the Columbus Ohio area! Check it out!!!

This pie brought on some conflicting feelings. My head says 7.6, my heart says 8.4 so I’ll settle in the middle with an 8.1 Probably one of the crispiest crusts I’ve ever eaten, and that’s a great thing. Just the right amount of sauce and toppings. Excellent taste and stretch of the cheese. Good pie, real good.

I hate going 9 anything, but daaaaauyyummm. Right up my alley. Extra crispy crust, not too much sauce, great quality ingredients. 9.2. That’s a review.

Great pizza, a little sweet

Really good pizza. Sauce has a "kick" to it that makes it unique. Thicker crust than most.

One bite, everyone knows the rules...Phenomenal pizza man. Perfect bake, sauce has good tang just a knockout. Solid 8.9 all day. Do yourself a favor and check these guys out. Great owners, they’re the ones making the pies. El presidente time to come back to the great state of Ohio!

Alright Frankie.. This is actually the second time I have been to Sexton’s, and boy let me tell you these guys know how to do pizza. First time I was there I went with the classic pepperoni, which was fantastic. My 8.7 score belongs to that pizza. The second time, I thought I’d try the “Kevin Bacon”, one of their specialty pies. It’s was good, however the bacon was much sweeter than I had anticipated. It wasn’t terrible, but not something I’d order again. The sweetness just gave the pizza an off taste. I’d score that one a 6.5. Other than that, this place was great. Go there. Give these guys your money. Thank me later.