Shirky's Pizza Zone

Pizza scores: Value-5.3 large pizza is more like a medium but with Large prices) Bake-8.2 very good Bake. Nice crisp for a tavern style. Toppings-7.3 plenty of toppings. Decent quality. Crust-6.2 Although baked very well, very mediocre tasting Sauce- 7.6 quite sweet but helped the crust taste All in all a decent pizza for a high price point

Shirkys in Carrol, Ohio is very good. Great crust loaded with toppings and fresh. I did the pork pizza definitely will get it again it was heavy and reasonably priced. Cool place to swing by or take a trip to have some beers, pizza and wings.

Despite this place being one of favorite small town pizza joints, it deserves an honest review. The pizza has gotten somewhat pricey and is inconsistent in recent years. When it’s cooked right, it’s one of my favorite pizzas - Crispy & great flavor, but thats not always the case. Often times it’s very doughy & undercooked lately. Nonetheless, I love the atmosphere, owners, and people.

Solid pizza. Sauce is tangy. Crisp crust. Good flavor. Solid

Nice crust! Cheese has a little bite. I feel other scores are exaggerated. I’ll come back but in the 8’s is crazy.

Crispy crust. Love the peps

Best Pizza by far!!!!

Buttery crust. Good pepperoni and sauce. Will have again.

Good pizza, good people

Honestly Frankie, best pizza in Ohio I have had so far. Best pizza in southern Ohio and the people who own it are extremely nice. Very clean place, fun for all ages. Good place to come and watch the big game and grab a beer. Impressive!