Slice on Broadway - East Liberty

Seriously good slice! Nice and thin, no flop, nice crunch, and solid flavors. If you want a NY style this is a great spot.

Didn't expect much. Honestly fantastic! Nice and thin NY style, with a chewy tough, and even a bit of char on the crust.

The Owl House

Decent

My uncle and I tried 3 different pizza locations today. Originally it was Mineo's and Aiello's however this was thrown in at the end. THE GOOD The crunch of the dough. The zesty peps and the stringy cheese all did it for me. This was a really good pie. THE BAD I wouldn't necessarily call this "BAD" but they have a unique sauce that definitely tastes better fresh out the oven than once the pie is sitting for a little. That being said I was completely full and I still managed to eat 3 slices of this pie because it was so good.

Even after eating pizza all day from different places and having a full stomach, this place stood out above all the rest. Crispy. Excellent ingredients. I only wish i lived closer to eat it more often. Keep up the great work. 🍕👏🏽

Second review. Had to try it again to confirm this is now my go to pizza spot in Pittsburgh. Moved here a year ago and been looking for decent NYC pizza. This is the closest I’ve found.

Best NYC pizza I can find in Pittsburgh.

a real impressive slice. not too greasy but just the right amount. the crust is what makes it a winner

Definitely the most NYC slice in the city. Always hits the spot

By far the best pizza I’ve had in PGH. Could be crispier but everything else is solid

Really liked the crust and pepperoni but the flop was a bit much!

Best place to get a single slice in Pittsburgh. Large, NY style slice. Crunchy crust, tasty cheese and sauce. Pretty good!

Pretty, slightly chewy, little crispy, decently floppy, NY style crust with above average if unremarkable sauce, great cheese and roni cups

Boy oh boy... How did this make it so far in last years pizza bracket? Are the different slice on Broadway locations different pizza? This was above average, greasy, and floppier than a limp salmon. Smdg

Great pizza for a great price!