Sugar River Pizza Co. - Verona

No way, this is Pizza in Wisconsin? Really not better than the best Frozen pizza, but I did enjoy the sauce and Breezy did a beautiful job so I gave them a couple tenths more than they deserve.

Alright Frankie… at first glance we’ve got a nice looking football pizza. There is a nice crispy look to the cheese and the crust. As I grab a slice, there is flop. There is a little grease in the cheese but the cheese is bubbled up nice and has a good taste. The sauce is your average football pie sauce. Pretty decent crunch on the crust. Overall to me, this is just like a Papa Johns/Pizza Hut type football pie but tastier.

Phenomenal tang in the sauce. Crust was fluffy but a nice crisp. Totally high end ingredients. Love this pie! Spin dip was fire too. 🔥

Gimmick pizzas but very good. Basic pizza not the best.

Solid doughy for a thin crust nice crisp tho overall solid

Average pizza I would eat it again

wings are so so. taco pizza is good but MESSY

Got wings for an app, 10 piece, got 9 about the size of my thumb. Taco pizza is great, though.

A little flop, but amazing cheese. And crust. Pepperoni was amazing!!! Also the bone in hot wings were amazing

Some of the best pizza around. The New Glarus location is a wee bit better (probably a 9.1). But this pizza is absolutely delicious!