The Brothers Restaurant

Blend between bar pie/thin crust. Great family run restaurant

Bit of flop, solid crust, good flavor, nothing crazy

Lost in the sauce….I wanted this to be better. It looks good, it feels good, and it’s cooked to perfection. The sauce isn’t sweet or spicy…its just there. Its like an unenthusiastic h%$d job

We sat with the locals at stop #6. The Brothers Restaurant has a fantastic bar pie. The crust is crispy with the perfect crunch, the cheese has proper flavor -which has been lacking at a lot of places - the pie could use a bit more sauce but #PizzaMoon success we found a great place without Portnoy!! Yummy

An all time favorite when I was in the Bank. Packed bar at 2 pm. With your original coors type worker folk. Killer bar pies still resonate here! Recommend going antiquing next door and cap off with a bar pie and cold one.

Very solid old school Italian venue with rock solid crispy-but-not-too-thin Bar Pie. The crumbled sausage was amazing but can’t factor in to this review, right? Well….

Slightly higher score if it wasn’t for cheese. Nice thin crust.

Solid bar pie. Great crust. Best immediately after coming out. Would be higher, slightly too cheesy.

One sentence everybody knows the rules. I’ve been here once before and had the plain and wasn’t impressed so this time I get the Supreme Special loaded with everything under the sun and this time it was better but it still gets nasty as it cools.

How has Dave not reviewed this? #1 Bar pie is Pete and Eldas but this is a close #2.

Was in the area and saw the high score , decent pie , not a fan of the cheese or the sauce but the service was really good .

I like the thin crust. Way too much cheese and very little sauce, and kind of greasy. Sauce was pretty decent, I wish there was more. They’re known more for the grandma, Sicilian and specialties I believe, but the plain pie is alright

Bar pie

Overall a really good pie. Crispy thin and great quality cheese. Sauce was lacking in flavor.

Best in town. Super thin, great crust, a little tang. If I asked for it well done, it would be higher. Take the trip for this one!

Great bar pie, crust stays crisp with good bite, sauce is great.

Fantastic bar pizza, moderate flop with great char and cheese flavor. Definitely a must have if you’re in the area

The best thin crust pizza in town. Usually consistent. When cooked right it is very crispy with good char. Highly recommend. Maybe order well done to be sure it’s crispy.

Nice thin crust bar pie. A little char. I should have ordered light cheese and well done. Next time.

Best bar pizza on the Jersey Coast. Go for the cooked well.