The Hickory Inn

This place has been around for 60 years and the last 40 years that I’ve been coming the pizza has remained consistently excellent. It’s a knife and fork pie when coming to the table hot but once it cools a bit the floppiness is gone . Good undercarriage and slight crunch , good crust , sweet sauce, I just love it and thinks its best in Ohio for this type of pizza . When friends or customers come from out of town it’s a required stop !

Solid pie. Fluffy crust. Good bit of flop.

Good football pizza.

Wonderful service but the place was not very clean altogether. Pizza needed to hangout longer in the oven. Ingredients were fresh and sauce had good flavor however just not cooked long enough.

Good sauce tang - little too cheesey.

Ordered pizza for take out. Was told it would be ready in 35 minutes, arrived 40 minutes after order was put in, was told my order was not even ready to be put in the oven yet! Piss poor customer service and they just lost another patron!

Real greasy and a lot of cheese. A lot of flop. Actually had a good flavor. Not a bad slice

Little different than previous Hickory Pizzas I’ve had...what happened to the curled up pepperonis?? Great flavor though! 8.8! Beats out Giordanos for first place...