The Original Mario's Pizzeria

8.1 legit score incredibly underrated. The undercarriage was amazing and crispy. Sauce was a banger. Tastes like the best of the best of boardwalk pizza

Great boardwalk pizza. They have a great Wednesday night special that you can’t beat. Sauce is fantastic and the crust is crispy and delicious.

The wife and I just left this place.. I have been to hundreds of pizza places over the last few years traveling as far away as 3 to 4 hours for pizza and this place has been in my backyard the entire time. I literally tried my hardest to find something wrong with this pie and I could not the undercarriage is perfect the cheese and sauce ratio is spot on Absolutely 0 flop. The only thing I can recommend to the owners is to get the word out more

Great pizza, the sauce makes it

*New Ownership review A lot of hype behind this pie. It was said to be the OG Joe’s Pizza Recipe, which is the Famous Bruni’s recipe. It’s close! The crust is a bit too dense, sauce is almost spot on. Cheese is different. It’s very close and still an excellent pie. Keep working on the crust! Maybe add soda water. Seems like the dough was pressed and not hand tossed, judging by the wrinkles and separation. Same issue the old Mario’s pie had. While this won’t stop my trips to Bruni’s, it’s good enough to hold me over. Still the best pie in town.

Solid slice, not greasy. Really small. Simple very simple slice but it’s good. Crust is really good. Could use more cheese. Sauce is decent

Very good tasting sauce. Nice place with good prices. Definitely going to order again. Fries are very good also.