The Red Tomato Pizzeria

Thin crust, minimal flop. Great sauce, geeat ingredients. Solid rural PA Pizza. Would absolutely make a regular pizza spot.

Had two orders of their Italian slice. Crunchy undercarriage with a little flop. Great slice

Really nothing special about the pizza. A little greasy, floppy, and no real flavor to it.

It’s an ok pie. It’s very bland with little flavor. Ok crunch

Their margherita pizza was super tasty.. would definitely go back here

Despite how it came out in the picture, my pizza here was almost void of sauce. Some dried sauce close to the crust, almost none under the cheese. Strange from a place called the red tomato. Overall my pizza was dry and unexciting. They did have some killer garlic knots though!

Had it a second time around. Very good. Good taste. Nice undercarriage.

Bath location (not in the app), I did the extra large round just for fun, extremely light and floppy crust (not always a bad thing depending on my mood) but makes up for it in amazing flavor (don’t bother with extra sauce)… fresh out of the oven on a Friday night Tomato pie is delish as well and maybe slightly better than the plain… very thick crust but mostly light and fluffy except for the crispy undercarriage… maybe went a bit heavy on the Romano cheese for my taste but overall very impressed Great people that work there too, bonus points

Grandma Pie

Pizza made by kids??? Was passing through and found this gem in the middle of nowhere. Pizza was made by a legit 17 year old and god damn it was really good. Very tasty, crust was crunchy, no flop and the garlic knots were icing on the cake. Enjoy!!!

Really nice pizza. Good crust, sweet sauce perfect amount of cheese. A little greasy and could have been in a little longer.

Lots of flop, nothing special.

Sicilian slice is average, possibly a bit below. The regular slice is the way to go.

A 7.1 is a wildly high review. This pizza is average at best. And the square slice!? Way worse then the original. It’s a 4.6!

Had their square slice before which I’d give a 7.9. Regular slice and overall I’ll say 7.1. Solid place