I’ve been coming here my entire life. That being said, yes this pie LOOKS really good and it had some good qualities.
Good: Stellar appearance and little to no grease. Not too thin but also not too fluffy. Cost is very reasonable at about $15 a per pie.
Bad: very floppy, no crisp even from the crust. Taste was slightly above average.
Granted, I ordered about 45 minutes before they closed so maybe they were just tired or had a long shift.
I’ll continue coming back though, everything else at this place is awesome.
Any of their square pies are to die for and they are top tier with their subs as well.
This place is a staple in the true town of Vestal, away from the college. If you’re looking for a hidden gem to try something new, this is your next stop.
(Try the Thanksgiving diner sub, you’ll thank me later)
