Third Proof Pizzeria

You cannot cook a slice of pizza any better than Third Proof. Exceptionally thin, crispy, with a perfect char. Undercarriage was a 10! It is what carried the score. The flavor was okay because I think it lacked sauce to complement the cheese and basil. But really good stuff!

Honestly, it looks better than it actually was. The flavor was great, it was light and well done, but it felt like there was something missing. I think it may be too thick for my liking, the Dave Portnoy “undercarrriage” was not up to my standard but, it’s worth trying and definitely worth going to. 7.9

Near perfect pizza, great taste and the best crust I’ve probably ever had.

All 3 pies were excellent

Wow. Phenomenal and crispy…..great spot

The real deal. Great crisp, no flop, light on the cheese and tasty sauce.

Fantastic edge crust, up there with the very best. Gets a bit sloppy toward the center tho. Tasty sauce in good proportion. A wonderful pie!

Top 5-10 I’ve ever had

All around excellent pie. The dough is really next level.

Great pizza! Ordered the hot honey and the New Haven style, the latter was better (sorry no picture of that one). Great crisp, perfectly cooked. Dave will come to visit soon, I am sure!

Amazing pizza! Sauce has a nice tang. Great crispy undercarriage. If you like New Haven style then look no further!

New Haven Style was my favorite but all 3 were great. Definitely up there for the best in the area. Place was packed order early.

Unreal

One of the best pizzas I have ever had. Cooked perfectly crisp, cheese is grande and they use an amazing oil splashed ontop. Make sure to ask for that oil drizzle. If Dave goes, I’m gonna say an easy 9.2! That’s a review!

Amazing crust, good sauce, just the right char, light and airy. Maybe I’m a little biased bc it’s in my neighborhood, but still excellent. 🍕 🍕 🍕

Incredible pie. Crust was to die for.

Pizza was amazing. Had the New Haven pie. Love the extra sauce the pie comes with as well as the light crisp crust.