Times Square Pizza & Bagels

The white is top notch! Tried 3 different slices and got a pie to go. Worth the drive!

Easy 8.1 on the cheese. Best pizza in the Temecula Valley. Also got the Salmon Bagel Sammich. Thuh besss. I highly recommend

Absolute perfection! A solid, 8.9 ! Love this place !

Looks great! Taste is above average, a bit too much flop and a LOT of grease. Overall a good spot for a slice!

Got the NY style upside down cheese pizza it was pretty darn good!

Ordered cheese and got half cheese half pepperoni. I ain’t really complaining. Lol the cheese is ridiculously good.

One bite

It was good

Solid NY style, hits at a pretty base level but it’s hits all the notes and I can’t complain.

Got a plain ole cheese, Portnoy style. Bottom is very chewy, flavor is okay. Sauce is pretty alright. Maybe they were having an off night ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I’ve been craving ny style pizza and this hit the spot, everything I’ve been wanting. Great pizza and service.

Nice slice! Paper thin and crispy. Light and flavorful. Will stop here on my way through Temecula.

Great crust, a bit to greasy for me, their house sauce is really good!

Solid slice. Great favor. A little to greasy. When it’s freshly made I use a bunch of napkins to sop up the grease

Kinda greasy. No real tang on the sauce. Could have cooked few more minutes but all around a solid pie.

Some of the best pizza I can get in this area. Very thin crust, burning hot, and excellent flavor. No flaw whatsoever. I highly suggest checking it out.

Great slice. Thin and crispy. It would be in the 8’s if it wasn’t so greasy, but this is a NY slice. Good cheese. I’ll eat this all day.

One bite everybody knows the rules.....I’m no expert on New York pizza never even been there, but I will say from all the slices I’ve tried in the Temecula Murietta Menifee area this is the best. Definitely football style pizza. It was light crisp and had an excellent flavor to the sauce. The owner said he was from New York end it was authentic. Also had a calzone some garlic knots and wings. All were average. The slice was the real star. I would highly recommend if you’re in this area, prices are extremely reasonable and the staff is friendly. This is my new go to spot for a slice.