One Bite App | Pizza Review App by Barstool Sports
Download
Home
Top Restaurants
Tipsy Tomato Bar and Pizzeria

Tipsy Tomato Bar and Pizzeria

656 New Haven Avenue, Derby, Connecticut
3,437 views•147 likes
stoolpresidente on One Bite Pizza App

stoolpresidenteVerified

6/6/23 10:00 PM

Pizza Review
anthony.rosati19/24/25, 5:28 p.m.
Pizza review

7.9

0 likes
Pizza Review
spencer.jenney9/3/25, 10:57 p.m.
Pizza review

7.7

Traditional Pie
0 likes
Pizza Review
hudsonvalleypizzaking6/15/25, 9:13 p.m.
Pizza review

8.4

Great pizza for just outside of New Haven. Sauce and cheese were perfectly balanced. Crust was good too just wish it was slightly more well done
0 likes
Pizza Review
david.mcdevitt7/11/24, 3:56 p.m.
Pizza review

9.7

About as good as it gets. Delicious NH style pie. Nice job guys!
0 likes
Pizza Review
mg064015/10/24, 10:12 p.m.
Pizza review

8.3

Popeye pizza
0 likes
Pizza Review
ali.glenn12/1/23, 10:29 p.m.
Pizza review

0.0

0 likes
Pizza Review
william.finnegan10/22/23, 5:56 p.m.
Pizza review

7.8

Very close to Bar pizza. Sauce had a little kick!
1 like
Pizza Review
ryan.rutherford10/19/23, 1:55 a.m.
Pizza review

7.7

Opened in 2017, this is a sports bar strip mall pizzeria trying to cash in on imitation coal-fired New Haven style pizza; not to say that’s a bad thing, this is just a more modern take on traditional old school New Haven style well outside of the Pizza Mecca. Thinnish, but not razor thin, crispy, but not quite on par with New Haven crunch, the dough is plenty tasty but has a tad more hang & flop and not nearly as firm as I anticipated. Despite the slight lack of true crisp, the undercarriage is decently darkened but unable to duplicate that classic coal oven char. However, the crust is deliciously crunchy and quite possibly the single best attribute of the pie. A questionably quality shredded mozzarella blend, the cheese leans more towards generic. Despite a flavorfully sharp & tangy taste, the cheese is harboring a ton of unmanageable grease. Overly oily, the salty discharge from the gushing grease overpowers most of the flavor from the sauce. Lacking in volume & zest, the sauce is rather underwhelming; with a basic pizza flavor, the sauce isn’t distinctive or substantial enough to overcome the excess oil. Even with plenty of room for improvement, this is a solid pie overall, much better than traditional strip mall football pizza, just not real deal New Haven style, but certainly close enough and perfectly fine for this area. Not quite travel-worthy but it certainly could be with just a few adjustments.
6 likes
Pizza Review
alex.overkamp9/26/23, 8:00 p.m.
Pizza review

8.7

Very good. Dave would have given this high if his baseball bet didn’t go south. Great crisp— new haven thin crust style without TOO much char. Full Italian menu as well. I will be back . Next time I’ll try the white clam pie.
0 likes
Pizza Review
david.anderson209/3/23, 11:51 p.m.
Pizza review

9.3

Excellent pizza.
1 like
Pizza Review
largecheesetotheface6/9/23, 5:28 p.m.
Pizza review

7.9

Thought long and hard almost went into the 8's. Quality pie but wouldn't drive an hour for it.
0 likes
Pizza Review
couts506/9/23, 5:22 p.m.
Pizza review

8.3

Good crisp, little too greasy for my liking.
1 like
Pizza Review
lolliandpop5/14/23, 6:48 p.m.
Pizza review

8.2

Very thin pizza, no flop. Good tang in the cheese. No extra toppings needed. REALLY good pizza and the waiter hustled it up. Def worth the drive!!
1 like
Pizza Review
mike.fernino5/14/23, 5:48 p.m.
Pizza review

8.5

Worthy of the hype. These pies are tangy, thin crust, crunchy with some nice char. Great flavor. They go down easy. Yum!
2 likes
Pizza Review
pizzavore11/9/22, 2:38 a.m.
Pizza review

8.3

Large cheese pizza, 8 Spicy Garlic wings and a Saxon Woods root beer with friends for lunch on a Monday Pro: Nice thin crust with a saucy coastline. Great cook to the pizza, a real CT quality pie. Cons: First few bites can get a little greasy but when cooled it tastes great with the sauce, cheese and thin crust. Verdict: Well above average pizza with a great cook to it. And the wings were possibly the best I ever had, so this place is really fantastic. *I added .5 to the score for the best wings anywhere combined with strong pizza - This place is great and worst a return visit for sure Wings are a 9.7
3 likes
Pizza Review
subdiver10/29/22, 10:49 p.m.
Pizza review

8.4

Great pizza, sauce filled with natural flavor, good undercarriage and nice thin crunchy crust. Surprised that it’s cut like Apizza New Haven style but NOT really like New Haven style. The regular pie is a high score of 8.4 and their garlic pie is a 7.7. It hit the spot for our pregame World Series party. GO PHILLIES! (8.4/10)
1 like
Pizza Review
colin.ford10/18/22, 5:16 p.m.
Pizza review

8.3

Little floppy but yummy
1 like
Pizza Review
scooter.baz2310/12/22, 12:12 a.m.
Pizza review

8.6

Really good
1 like
Pizza Review
justin.turner9/7/22, 2:11 a.m.
Pizza review

8.6

Not particularly New Haven style, but very good pizza. Lots of flavor with a hint of garlic, decent hold, notable cheese to sauce ratio. Thinner than it looks.
1 like
Pizza Review
daveturner9/7/22, 12:18 a.m.
Pizza review

8.2

First bite had the taste of garlic, guessing Wisconsin cheese?. Definitely not Apizza style you would expect from the area but a pleasant surprise nonetheless Hidden gem, as a bonus local IPA was really good to accompany the pie!
1 like
Pizza Review
kevin.price4/5/22, 10:31 p.m.
Pizza review

8.6

If colony grill and Santillo’s had a kid this is it. The first bites that oil gives incredible bite into the really thin crispy crust. Sauce taste incredible with garlic and the hint of dusted cheese, did I say it has garlic cuz it’s got garlic. The cheese very similar to colony grill is we’re the majority of flavor comes from and matches the Jersey style bar crust for a sensational pie. The place is in the corner of a strip mall and totally unassuming but my god is it one hidden gem and worth the trip!! Place is a must try!!’
6 likes
Pizza Review
megan.conway2/28/22, 6:42 p.m.
Pizza review

9.1

Love their pizza!!
3 likes
Pizza Review
checo752/27/22, 8:32 p.m.
Pizza review

8.3

3 likes
Pizza Review
gbonz2/26/22, 2:00 p.m.
Pizza review

8.9

Best pizza!! No flop, perfect amount of cheese Sauce is tasty Great dough Pres you have to check this place out!!
2 likes
Next
(203) 732-7931
656 New Haven Avenue
Derby, Connecticut 06418
Something not look right?
Suggest an Edit
Barstool Bets - Barstool Gambling
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

© 2025 Barstool Sports. All rights reserved.

Terms of UsePrivacy PolicyContent PolicyContact UsApp Support