Tommy's Pizza

Unique crust (think Pizza Hut Pan, but lighter) and sauce. Unlike all other local places.

Girlfriend wanted veggie so that’s what we got. It’s tasty. Crust is just shy of being deep dish, but no flop because of that. I liked the crust and sauce, though the cheese was a little plasticy. Certainly a decent pie.

The pizza was overall good but something about the sauce was off. The cheese was great and stringy. I recommend to anyone who is looking to eat nice local pizza.

A local Facebook post asked for best pizza places in york and adams county. of 80 plus responses about 20 said this place. Juice isnt worth the squeeze. hate to say it but it seems like a quality frozen pizza. reminds me of a little lighter costco slice

Tommy’s is a pizza that people either love or hate. Not sure if it’s nostalgia or what but I fall in the love category. Football style, with a slightly sweet sauce. Can be a little greasy sometimes, but in my opinion in a good way. Perfect hangover pizza.

Tough one here. . . Sauce and style immediately reminded me of Pizza Hut. It was good but not great - Side note - I would travel for their hoagies . . . Easily in the mid 8’s

Nasty pizza. Unfortunately here in Pennsylvania, there’s not a lot of options for good pizza. Gettysburgnps pretty touristy and brings together a variety of people who don’t know what good pizza actually taste like, and think that this is actually great. This is your stereo typical late night party pizza that has too much cheese and sauce. Not a lot of flop, some crunch, not much grease, but leaves you feeling disgusting after you eat it. Most every other option in town is better than this place. I’m also from CT and my personal scores are based on the best pizzas in the world.

Good sauce

Subpar pizza. Not cooked long enough and super greasy. Crust was good and sauce was really sweet.

Nice flavor and good crisp on the crust. A little too greasy for me, but solid pie.

Super small slice for the price. Had good crisp, ample sauce but little flavor. Too much cheese. This slice was nearly only one bite to finish it.

Its good pie, crusty, saucy and nostalgic.

Cheese slice

Went here thinking it would be pretty decent based off the reviews. Let me tell you, it was one of the worst slices I’ve ever had. It tastes like the pizza you get at a 7-11, that has been sitting around all day drying up. The only reason it doesn’t fully dry up though, is because they put a lot of tasteless sauce on it. Do yourself a favor, don’t go here.

Nice crust. Sweet sauce. Very good pie.

All of the locals raved about this place.. 2 dollar slice and it tasted just like a Pizza Hut personal pan pizza. Very disappointed.