Tony Boloney’s Pier Village

I want to say this off the top that this place is no longer our beloved Tony Boloney’s and unfortunately it’s a major downgrade. Sauce is watery, cheese has minimal flavor, crust is crispy but is once again lacking flavor. I’ll give it plus .01 cause the undercarriage is good

solid pizza not great but not bad. nice beach pizza i like it but crust could be less bland

Came at the end of the day staff was very friendly and pizza was very good run to come get a slice here

Flop aint too pretty. Sauce is ight. Cheese sub-par. Decent slice

I always rate based on a plain pie. Somehow and idk how but they made an oops on our order but I wasn’t even mad because this was delicious. Crust was lite, thin, crispy and delicious. If this was as good as it was I know a plain cheese is probably just as good. Loved it.

This is quality plain slice, with a taste one would expect from boardwalk pizza. Maybe even a little above expectations. Thin and crisp overall, with a crunchy crust. They also offer a large variety of specialty slices with hipster names

Pretty good.good cheese

Ok quarantine review time jersey shore style.....Toney Boloneys... Really disappointed here.. I’ve been to the two locations in Hoboken and Jersey City and have them a great review. Here shocked me... on the surface looked very good but once it was plated the disappointment set it.... SUPER FLOPPY... so much so that it fell apart in my hands.... and Grease!, you ain’t seen grease like this pizza was putting out... but the cheese was good and the sauce was decent.... 5.9 that’s the review

Standard pizza, had great crunch with stand flavor. Standard sauce.

Not great. Too floppy and was given to me warm, not hot. Average pizza at best and for the NY/NJ area it is not great. Beach pizza

Excellent pizza and great undercarriage

Good tasting cheese. Would consider this an average, yet decent local pie.

pizza was good, don’t not get the cheesy garlic bread tho

Very hot when it came out and a very tangy sauce. Very heavy pizza for sure it had a lot going on.

Good tangy sauce good crust and nice amount of cheese very surprised it was this good!

Nothing to be ashamed of at all, football pizza, sweet sauce

Major Jersey Shore Flop and tons of grease. Crust was pretty good and the sauce was decent.

Greasy pizza (sopping with grease), Major NY flop Flavor profile: late night drunk pizza. Meh