Tony's Pizza

Had super high hopes based on the outside of this place and even the inside with the classic red seats and it’s cash only but alas this slice was average. Way too much greasy not enough crisp and too doughy. Flavor was good I just think this needed less cheese and more sauce and time in the oven. That’s a review

Nothin spectacular, but the slice was pretty doughy and filling which was a plus. Spot has a whole cake and desert bar in addition to ice cream which I didn’t get to check out, but that’s a plus right? Not super greasy and decent flop. Inoffensive slice.

Words can’t explain how utterly disappointing this place is. Over cooked heat lamp garbage pizza. Maybe order fresh pie 6.5 at best. But not the place. The knickerbocker location is simpler and does a better job. This was insulting

This slice has soooo much potential. Heavy on the dough almost Long Island style vet doughy and undercooked at times. Good amount of cheese and sauce has some taste those are positives. A raw and undercooked crust is another fault. Use less dough and cook it more and would be much better.

Great slice, a little greasy but great sauce and crust. Fantastic staff and great service!

Little greasy, but crispy with great taste. 100% football pizza. Employees were friendly and professional. Definitely recommend this place

Nice service and a quality neighborhood pizza.

Very very very very good. Definitely get the margarita slice. Get two.

The Brooklyn's own slice ( chicken, pepperoni, fresh ricotta, soppressata )