Tony's Place Italian Restaurant and Pizza

Tony's pizza

This thing showed up hot—like fresh-out-the-oven hot. I crushed three slices before I even thought about anything else. Cheese was still bubbling, sauce had that little tang I like, and the cheese blend? Fire. Real deal flavor all around.

This was a decent slice. Little greasy cause of the reheat, lacked under carriage. Simple run of the mill slice, so little upset about the $5 spent.

Friends

Mr. Ice is an automatic .5+ but besides that buffer, this pizza is near perfect…two slices and a drink for $8 is hard to pass up when I’m driving by in the work truck. Good crisp, minimal flop…a little greasy, but it’s not a deal breaker.

One bite festival really good pie

Great pizza! Nice tangy sauce, NO grease, and a great looking under carriage. would come back anytime!

A little floppy but had great taste and texture. Nice crunch. Not too burnt and fairly light. Def recommend.

Wasn’t anything special. During the flop cheese fell off. Pizza was very greasy..Used napkin to remove some of the grease. Sauce barely had any flavor and the cheese was just ok. The crust was the best part of pizza. Crust was crisp and cooked well.

Ice Mannnnn!!! Was not expecting to see Elio when I walked in. Pizza was decent - no need to hedge.

8.4

Man, the crust was epic - crispy on the bottom, fluffy on the inside, and the sauce stayed evenly applied even when you folded and unfolded the slice. The sauce could have had a bit more flavor, but it was tasty (just subtle). The cheese was disappointing as it didn’t have that ‘bite’ of quality mozzarella and was almost waxy. Overall really good and I’d recommend over many others.

Reminds me of Papa Gino’s. But I mean that in a good way. Solid pizza. Nothing fancy. Just a nice fastball right down the pipe. 95mph on the black

There’s no way this reaches an 8. Too doughy and the the cheese is too heavy. Still a good neighborhood spot. You’re welcome for the reality. Check in and out.

I don’t know how Prez gave this an 8.5. This is slightly above average New England bar pizza. Not even in the same ballpark as places like Sally’s or Papa’s. Sauce was okay. Cheese was okay. Crust was thick and doughy. Would taste great at 2 am after lots of beers. Now where near an 8.5 though.

Great sauce. Tasteful slice worth the trip

Would have been a 9.2 rating but had a major flop. Crust tasted superlative, sauce was spot on, cheese decent, pepperonis were ok. All together a fantastic slice but the flop needs some attention.

TONY’S PLACE IN WEST ROXBURY 8.9 CHEDDAR JACK REVIEW #31

Been going to Tony’s for 30 years and it is still one of the best pies in Boston. A classic Italian style pizza with the best pepperonis. So. Damn. Good.