Umberto's of Lake Grove

This slice was simply perfect. Decent crisp, tangy sweet sauce and nice ratio to cheese. The undercarriage was on point and every bite was so enjoyable. In fairness this was a fresh margarita slice, not. Plain cheese…but nonetheless the best in the area.

Nice little flop, sauce had a very nice flavor, crust had a nice initial crunch but was doughy afterwards. Undercarriage was a little burnt and I think they rushed because it was not ready upon arrival so I would love to come back when the pie is finished and no added pressure is there on the workers

Large amount of flop. Very pleasant sauce with JUST the right amount of zing; perfectly tickled my tastebuds I was apprehensive about the burnt crust at first but came around on it eventually. Very good slice, not an ace by any means, but a solid #3/4 innings eater.

Good solid slice

Very good

Looks better than it taste. Just a very boring slice. Zero flop and good crisp to the bottom but kind of tough and doughy at the same time. Just very boring. Square slice has a little more flavor but still very boring. It’s definitely edible but zero excitement to either slice. If you’re a local it’s a spot but I wouldn’t drive for this.

Really good

Nope. I don't even want to talk about it. The most exciting part of the meal was the napkin I wiped my hands on after I was done.

Kinda tasteless, and burnt. Not impressed.

This is definitely one to travel for. It doesn't get much better than this. Perfect crisp crust, just the right amount of everything. Very flavorful and delicious. I highly recommend this place.

best grandma i’ve had from here. they can be inconsistent but this was very good

Great crisp. Not greasy. Tangy sauce.

This one is located in Lake Grove and not New Hyde Park Regular Slice 6.8 Margherita 6.9

Very good sauce and awesome crust

Finally!! A great slice! Thin. lil crisp. Little extra grease, but that never bothered me none, bring it on... great ratios: right amount of cheese, sauce great, the tiniest of flop, barely noticeable. I could get fat on this place, easy peasy. The local pizza places should stop by and try a slice.... up there game... ay ohhhh. Side note: everything is good here, not just the regular. I’m glad I work close by. I usually get the grandma or Sicilian...

Firm slice. Good amount seasonings in the sauce. Definitely, onecof Suffolk County's better pizzas.

A local spot that does the job. The Sicilian slice is an 8.1.

Burnt crust. Good drip