Village Square Pizza

The quintessential Sicilian. Heavy, greasy, but tasty. They didn’t have regular cheese slices available

Very average in NY. Very good anywhere else

Eye test- yum Execution - outstanding Ratio - perfect Dough - utterly amazing, crunch and taste on point Sauce - fantastic Cheese - great One above Scores are from local crack addicts. Ignore them No cute quote today Travel worthy - yes Grandma and eggplant both 8.2

Had a grandma and Margherita slice. Grandma was a 7.5, marg was a 7.0 for an average of 7.3. Good slice after a night out. Good cheese, sauce, and crunch. 👌

Solid square pizza. Just really greasy and not high quality. Crispy tho!

Really enjoyed the classic slice of cheese. Good sauce, good cheese, good crust = great slice.

it’s ok, would prefer more flop

Reheated - squishy. Pesto on grandma tasted off. Upside down slice was a bit redeeming, but the mediocre sauce ruined it. Workers were complaining the entire time about how tired they were and that they wanted to go home. I, too, wanted to go home after eating here

Honestly im impressed. They got me, damn good pizza

Pretty gooooooooood

I kept reading that this was a hidden gem that’s better Prince St, but I honestly didn’t think so. It was over cooked and the crust was way too crunchy. The flavor of the sauce was great but there wasn’t enough on the pizza to prevent it from drying out. There weren’t as many pepperoni cups on top as Prince St, although I did enjoy the sweet/spicy combo with Mike’s hot honey.

Good slice. Little greasy but good cheese and crust. 7.4 only due to extra grease

Grandma & upside-down Sicilian. Perfect crust, sauce has a lot of flavor, great cheese ratio.

Miles better than East Village Pizza. Super crispy undercarriage, fluffy crust, and a really nice tang/sweetness in the sauce. Not to mention it’s a dollar cheaper 🎤

I know I’m going a little off with the pesto grandma slice but this destroys their regular slice... it’s amazing

Soft, yet crunchy. Light, yet filling. Sauce and cheese were solid. Not my favorite style, but very good square pizza.