Villaggios Pizzeria

By far one of the best pizzas you’ll find in all of Alachua County. Other highly rated places here have either too much sauce, are deep dishes, or it’s an overrated chain. If looking for a good clean NY slice, this is it.

A really solid slice, definitely one of the best (if not THE best) pizza in Gainesville area that I’ve found. No flop, light sauce and pepperoni has a ton of flavor. Plus 3 mini garlic knots for only $1

It’s a 6.1 It’s good. It’s not great, it’s not worth driving from Gainesville for. The sauce needs salt and is watery. Crust could be more done. Knots are greasy, not buttery, which would be fine. It’s small town pie, it’s good. 6.1 that’s a review.

Just moved down here from NY so I now how’s it suppose to taste. This is best one in alachua county. No pizza in Gainesville or Newberry or any in alachua can top this right here. BX baby

Big fan of the crust. Sauce and cheese create a very harmonious flavor.

Great pizza, a little floppy. Great cheese, great sauce, great crust. Just a bit floppy for my taste.

Quality pie here at Villaggio's. I was pleasantly surprised at this slice for a place hidden out in Newberry. The sauce had a good flavor and perfect amount. Crust had a decent crisp and char. This place would undoubtedly be my go-to if I lived in the area. 7.8 that's a review.

Who knew Newberry had pizza game. This is a pretty solid pie. Little bit greasy up top but the crust was nice and crisp. Sauce had enough tang and cheese wasn't overwhelming. You can definitely taste the NY influence. Pretty good will eat again

Damn good pizza