Vinnie's Pan Pizza

Very good pizza. Very much like star Tavern or Columbia Inn. It just needed own identity. 🍕

top tier pan pizza, ask for it well done. perfect crust and cheese with great sauce. great service on top of everything

Wish I would have eaten this one at the restaurant instead of taking it to go. Still a very good pie.

The hulk. Good sauce. A bit too salty for me, but overall a great pie

very solid bar pie. it was sitting in the box for a solid 10 minutes so it took away from the freshness of it. but it’s cooked well-done and right up my alley crunch wise. great finish to full day of pizza eating with @thecomplord

Love this place!! Sauce has a great flavor and cooked perfect

Lives up to hype

Pizza looks welldone and crispy but the crust is soft . Reminded me of a frozen pizza in alot of ways . Not terrible but certainly not great .

Minimal crust but this pie is high high teir good crunch no flop

It was good the bottom could have been a little more well done , but worth the trip

The shredded pepperoni is up with the best I have ever had. I’d put it over Frank Pepe’s pepperoni in NH. It’s that good! This is my third or fourth pie - wanted to make sure it was their standard and it is just great! Surprised more people that I’ve spoken with don’t know the place.

Got my usual half pepperoni half cheese, but they had this unique sliced pepperoni that is a must try. I’m such a huge fan of crispy pies and this lived up to the this pan pizza expectation. Also great cheese to sauce ratio, definitely worth going out of the way for

Good pizza, but I wouldn’t drive out of my way for more. Thin crust for sure! I mostly tasted the cheese, not much of the sauce. It was slightly floppy…not a crispy undercarriage like I prefer. The top was cooked perfectly. I am curious of how the pepperoni pie tastes.

Fantastic, super thin!

Thin crust pizza that looked better than it tasted (I was expecting low to mid-8s by appearance alone). Decent undercarriage, though more chewy than crisp. The sauce wasn’t too distinctive. It's still a solid pie!

Fantastic flavor! Perfect crisp

Wish the bottom was a bit more crispy but regardless it was solid

I love when work takes be to different towns: Vinnie’s Pan Pizza, Millburn. Half plain/ half shoe string pepperoni. The texture of this pan pie cannot be beat!

Looks well done (as ordered) but undercarriage is soft with no crisp. The pie is pretty greasy especially given no crust handle to hold. Not my thing.