Wally's Cafe & Pizzeria

Disappointment is a generous word, you walk in and and see a poo machine from maybe the 40’s? keep walking and you’ll see the front counter. Look to your right and you’ll see three booths along with a basketball shooting net. Odd. But it gets worse. A LITERAL BED IN THE CORNER OF WHERE GUESTS ARE SUPPOSED TO EAT. I am sitting here on my kings throne typing this as my stomach is making irregular noises. Simply just a greaseball and not good pizza. I will be debating my life decisions later tn when my farts travel up to my face well i’m sleeping from the ungodly things this pizza has unleashed on my bowel.

7.8!!!! For spaghetti sauce pizza. Fuck outta here….

Good crisp on the crust, nice and thin very good pepperoni and cheese. Sauce was very good also. Gonna have to try the deep dish next.

Best deep dish I’ve had. Best pepperoni pizza I’ve had. Super consistent as well. Favorite pizza in Buffalo.

Killer buffalo pizza Sauce is a bit sweet but they offered a less sweet traditional sauce. I went with the sweet sauce and it was an excellent pizza.

Great pizza! Perfectly well done and crisp pepperoni to my taste , easy pizza to get on the daily ! 8.3 !!

What can I say about this. The weirdest slice of pizza I've ever had. This sauce... Tastes like..... What I could compare to spaghettio sauce with a lot of pepper. Perfect amount of pepperoni. Just strange. It didn't taste like pizza. It wasn't ... Good. Not disgusting but I wouldn't order again.

Middle of the road. A little greasy, good pepperoni, kind of floppy. A little doughy, strange sauce. Never have tasted a sauce like this used on pizza, seems more appropriate for pasta. Wings also weren't great, FYI. Very odd Blue Cheese.

Ordered a medium zah with boneless wings which I got garlic parmesan and honey BBQ. Tasted amazing, the pizza was a little to doughy maybe but overall taste was good. Only complaint really is the wings could of been cooked like an extra 2 minutes but overall I give it an 7.4

Good cheese and crust. Could use more sauce though