Wells Brothers Restaurant

Crust was very good texture wise. But the pizza lacked flavor. Very bland unfortunately. The appetizers (calamari and garlic bread) were very good. Sad to say for us the drive wasn’t worth it. Atmosphere is fairly nice tho!

Great crust, light and even toppings. Worth 20-30 min drive

Super thin crispy bar pizza. Atmosphere is a 9.4.

It’s good. Maybe a little over-hyped, but nothing to complain about. Super thin and crispy, good sausage.

I grew up on this pizza as a kid in the 90’s, moved away only to come back 30 years later and have it taste the exact same - it is just incredible pizza, in an incredible restaurant/bar. Crust, cheese, toppings are all that and more but IMO it is the sauce that takes it over the top. I honestly believe this is the best pizza in the country. I’ll go 9.5 in hopes I can find better, because I love good Za, but idk man. Wells Bros is legit great!!

Very solid pie. Paper thin crust and cooked well done.

Paper thin, cooked perfect, the toppings were great, but the sauce was a bit too sweet. Over all a great pie!

Always nice to come back and taste what a 9 pizza is supposed to taste like. Just a perfect tavern thin style with just the right amount of sauce that is tasty but doesn’t override the pizza. I didn’t even have to mention well done to the lady and they made this thin to perfection. Perfect crisp in every bite. This is the real deal folks.

Very thin and crispy. Cornmeal on the bottom. Very unique.

Quality Milwaukee pizza

Gas

Very good cracker thin crust and excellent toppings. Sauce was okay. Can’t complain, just didn’t blow me away like I’d hoped after Dave’s review.

Thin crispy great

Had one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time today! If you like that thin crust, square cut pizza, this is a must try in Racine, WI. I think this is now my #2 favorite right after Vito and Nicks. It was a medium Sausage and Jalapeño well done. Everything about it was perfect. Crust is out of this world!

I’ve been going to Wells brothers for over 30 years. I live in Milwaukee and it’s about a 45 minute drive but I still make a point of getting here whenever I can. It’s a very thin crispy classic Milwaukee style pizza atmosphere is just an old school vibe with a staff that is so wonderful. The quality of the ingredients in all menu items is fantastic. If there was only one kind of pizza I could eat for the rest of my life it would be Wells Brothers My score of 9.5 is basically the highest I would give have given to any pizza. I’m leaving a little bit of room for the possible holy grail of pizza but for me, this is the Pinnacle of my 55 years on the planet.