Wise Pies

Pizza is very undercooked, no undercarriage. Reminds me of buffet pizza. I remember when the other location was still in town and it was better.

Good NY style for the area. Crust is the highlight, light and tight. Sauce and cheese are on the bland side though and that brings it down for me.

Solid pizza for the area. About as close as you’ll get to NY style. Undercarriage gets a little weak if you don’t ask for well done. Sometimes you get a nice surprise of bubble trouble! Really just depends on who’s on that day. Overall, a solid pizza. Usually much better than others around if you are looking to buy by the slice or for a NY style

Very very thin and super floppy. Pretty good taste though.

Great crunch, super thin, best slice in Terre Haute.

Great crunch, no flop, delicious! My go-to lunch slice!

Nice and thin hand tossed crust. Could've used a bit more cheese. Not too greasy. Pretty good.

This pizza has a lot of potential but it was very underdone. Ton of flop and the crust on 1/2 of it was still very doey. I’ll try them again—could be closer to a low 7 if cooked properly

Zero flop, tangy sauce, crisp crust and good cheese ratio. Possibly the best pie in the city.

No flop, crispy, very good cheese, sauce needs some tang

Really good New York style pizza. I’d highly recommended