Wiseguy Pizza

Okay. Good sauce, somewhat crispy.

Great pizza, nice crisp, could use a little bit more cheese but the sauce was good and it was a nice light slice. Overall decent slice combos are great.

Not an awful tang on the sauce, but otherwise a mediocre slice. Decent drunk food pizza (still got a hangover the next day).

SILLY

Really enjoyed it. Slightly greasy, and not sure how the slices are, but the whole pie was great.

Unique flavors

Bad picture great pie!!

I’m being generous with 6 because does not meet the 7.6 others left. Slice only premade on rack and tossed in oven so crust was toast all the way to the bend in photo. Reheater guy was on another planet and left in oven way too long. Sauce and ingredients have potential but not worth the walk. Not what the name sounds like. We’re still hungry 30$ poorer.

Favorite pizza in the district. Solid NY style

The cheese slice was a 7.8; the godfather was a 6.7 (pepperoni and sausage). Good crunch on both crusts; no flop on the cheese slice; good cheese. Was not a fan of the godfather slice though.

Just a perfect football pie. No flop, great crust, great sauce and delicious blend of cheeses - a fantastic cheese pizza all around. Would highly recommend. Dave would like it I think, despite not being a south shore style bar pie (Poopsie’s, CCC, etc). Solid solid football pie

Rated based on the cheese slice. Pretty standard, had a nice chew but the crust is a little too thick. I'll come back bc it's decent but it's overrated.

(Plain only, speciality pepperoni was better) 50th review —> Wiseguys plain is nothing to write home about, and about as footballly as it gets, would stop in for a slice if I was in the area, but wouldn’t go out of my way for it.

Zero complaints. Nice char. Thin crust. Decent flavor. I’m on board. Definitely would go here again.

Spicy pep and grandma slice.

Pizza is pretty good for a late night spot. Got chicken parm slice and Nashville hot chicken because they were out of pepperoni. Taste and crunch were good, crust was ok.

Pretty solid

Underrated spot