Yankee Pie Apizza

Took my New Haven style virginity. Good pizza.

Simply Ahhhh-mazing!!!! Omg the crust is sooooo good!!

I’ve hit 43 states in the past 2.5 yrs and ate the best pizza across the country (check my profile). Can confirm New Haven is KING 👑! This place brought me right back to Wooster St!! GREATTT CHAR Perfect Ratio cheese-sauce Crispy chewy crust Would drive here if you are within 3 hrs. It’s totally worth it!!

I previously rated this pizza as one of the best in the NE Florida / SE Georgia area. Over the past two months or so I have seen a steady decline in the quality and consistency of the pies. I am very disappointed in the current cooks and am reducing my score.

Hands down, best in the area. Perfect sauce ratio, quality cheese, and they never skimp you on the toppings. Soo good! ONLY downfall is I don’t love a lot of char, so I do ask that it’s undercooked some, but it is my favorite.

Cheese was excellent. Tasty and plentiful. Crust was thin, with some char on the edges. Too much glop though as the thin crust couldn’t hold the volume of cheese. Sauce ok. Overall taste very good. Purported to be New Haven style but I don’t see or taste that. Wasn’t a wood burning oven and wasn’t flavorful dough. Dough was pressed by a machine and pizza was cooked partway on a metal screen. Pizza was served on a metal tray though, like in New Haven. Would try it again, maybe pepperoni next time

Begging for Portnoy! Pizza is solid and the owner can cut your hair at the salon next door!

This place is legitimate! Great crust, great quality cheese, beautiful sauce! Reminds me of my days up in the Northeast. I will come here every time I’m in Saint Mary’s! Best pizza in the area for sure!

Pretty good. Crust is crispy, toppings good quality, sauce tangy.

New Haven Style “ah-beets” Apizza. Fantastic pizza, crispy, beautiful. Worth the drive.