I had wanted to try this place out after seeing my boy Dave give them an 8.8 for their thinny thin pie. Little did he know that he actually reviewed their regular pie. Our waitress told us this and the staff was slightly disappointed as they thought he would review their actual thinny thin even higher! The thinny thin is just like it sounds as it has a nearly paper thin crust. I ordered a half cheese half pepperoni and ask for it cooked well and it was extremely crispy and held up perfectly under the weight of the cheese. The sauce had an awesome tang and the cheese was extremely flavorful! This is the second best bar pie I've had, behind the hot oil from colony grill!
Order now on Slice
Order Angeloni's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
spiceymeatballs12/23/22, 1:49 a.m.
Another place you need to travel to , what makes this pie other then the crust , is the sauce , great sauce
josh.morris511/15/22, 6:25 p.m.
some of the best I’ve ever had. Thin, crispy but not “burnt” tasting. Amazing
uhhdope10/17/22, 1:19 a.m.
Drove 45 mins out to order a pie. Walk in to see they are closing almost an hour early. Shame… 0
tedanon9/20/22, 5:34 p.m.
Really good bar pie. Went with the regular thin crust instead of the thinny thin. Cracker crunch crust in every bite with a hearty sauce and good bubbly burnt cheese.
sashkas8/15/22, 1:25 p.m.
Excellent. Thought the sauce could use a bit more pop but would drive far to come back!
izpiz7/10/22, 6:16 p.m.
Excellent thin pizza. Sauce has great tang. Cheese is a little greasy but in a good way.
john.ga6/23/22, 12:17 a.m.
I got the thinny thin. It’s overrated. Tony Ds is your better bet for Caldwell pizza
van.d16/4/22, 4:39 p.m.
Great slice, nice crunch, cheese to balance ratio seems pretty on point with an overall score of an 8.4. Good job guys!
thomasw044/23/22, 8:00 p.m.
Ordered a thinny thin and a thin crust. Thinny thin is 8.2 and thin is 8.4. Both slices were very good. The cheese had a good kick and the sauce was my favorite part. It was nice and sweet.
hvpizzaking4/11/22, 10:21 p.m.
TBH I really didn’t have high expectations for this place. Was expecting to be like Ralph’s in Nutley which was very overrated. Boy was I wrong, like REALLY wrong. Great coastlines, abundant amount of sauce (which had great flavors), great oils, tasty cheese, dough was flavorful, and zero flop. They make it known of Portnoy’s review here and had a confidence about their product. I would be just as cocky if it was my place. Not a bar pie guy but this was the best bar pie I’ve ever had!!! Almost walked back in to get there thinny thin pie. Worth the travel and lucky I had a wedding so I was close enough to stop in 💯💯💯!!!