Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Would be a 9 in other parts of the country but in NYC this is not a top 10 pie.

Good pie. Small. Easily ate the whole thing myself and I’m a little dude. The amount of pizza you get for $28 was disappointing but everything’s stupid expensive these days so maybe it’s just me.

Solid pizza. Slight crunch. No flop. See why Dave likes it.

Sensational

2nd best pizza ever

Insane bread, not too crispy, okay undercarriage

Very good. Wasn’t quite as high as Dave but good quality and sauce.

Sauce is the star. Very crispy. Light and delicious

It lived up to the hype!

Absolutely delicious!

Fine. Certainly not on par with John’s of Bleeker. Wouldn’t go out of the way for it.

It was very good! Unique and coal fire taste was very prominent in the best way!

Lot of chew for a thin pie. Good cheese to sauce ration.

Coal fire style really good. Just have a tough time with cold fire cause it’s not my style. Still recommend

Amazing, awesome sauce, crust, and cheese. I put meatballs on mine and I did not regret it. Amazing place I highly recommend.

Sauce is excellent