Brooklyn Char

Excellent crust, good undercarriage, almost zero flop. Sauce has really good flavor, love the crisp on the pepperonis, cheese tastes fresh, just wish there was a little more mozzarella to put it over the top

Gotta be one the best around

Great pizza!! Liked everything about it. Tried the Bee Sting & a pepperoni and sausage. Really enjoyed the bee sting!! Garlic knots were good also.

This pizza is just great. Simple shop. The dough is tremendous and the char/crunch is on point. Only wish it had a bit more char on top (the undercarriage is money). This is the standard pepperoni. This is my new Sunday football spot. Highly highly recommend

Had this a few times. Just a basic cheese. Very good crisp, great flavors and overall a one of a kind spot in the area.

Good Pizza, Good undercarriage, a tad bit heavy in the cheese. Needs a little more crisp. Overall great spot

Went this past May. I really wanted to like this. Nice color on the undercarriage. From everything I’ve read about this place I am sure this is a thoroughly researched and tested dough recipe, but you can see the cheese is not cooked, creating a very soggy slice. Also, WAY too heavy on the Parmesan post bake. The Bee Sting was better than the cheese and pepperoni pies we got. A lot of potential here if they lay off the parm and get a more even bake on the cheese. May be a QC problem with the preppers. For now a 6.4.

Crazy that you can get this in Indiana. Incredible pizza. Crisp, undercarriage and cheese. A little more sauce brings the score up

Very good crunch needs a little bit more sauce in my opinion but very good pizza

Finally real NY style pizza in Indiana. Limited selection. I had the onion and mushroom. Zero flop, great crisp, good sauce. Will definitely be my go to Pizza

Great undercarriage, flavor, and good crisp!