Top Restaurants

Brooklyn Square Pizza

Brooklyn Square Pizza

3620 Merrick Road, Seaford, New York

Pizza Review

0 likes

sicilianmagician on One Bite Pizza App

sicilianmagician

56 minutes ago

Stopped by on a whim. Saw a big window sign that says "buy and 2 sliced and get a free can of pepsi" Go inside, no sicilian at all. Got a regular and their upside down, asked about the free pepsi can, and am told its only 12-3...mind you i was there a few minutes after 3 and NOWHERE on the sign does it say only 12-3. Get to my truck, open the box, and the guy gave me a freaking middle slice. So they will not get a rating other than a 0 because what pizza place doesnt have sicilian out? The regular slice had way too much sauce and a thicker weird dough and under. The upside down tasted like salt. The dough, under and crust was solid, but couldnt taste much other than salt.

Order Brooklyn Square Pizza

Hungry? Order right now on Slice

Order now on Slice

Pizza Review

lucio.insinga3/21/25, 9:55 p.m.

8.7

A great tasting Sicilian slice. Brooklyn style. Tangy sauce, awesome crust very fluffy and crunchy and flavorful. An absolutely great slice.

Pizza Review

dave09118/17/24, 11:08 p.m.

6.9

Was excited to try this place after seeing the rave reviews for their NJ location but seems this one falls short. This style of pie needs an excellent sauce and this one is just ok, kind of bland. Needs more cheese as well. The crust is actually the highlight and has a great balance of light and fluffy while being crispy.

Pizza Review

theperfectopieguy7/5/24, 5:31 p.m.

6.7

Decent to say the least. Interior is not great, but the slice makes up for it! One complaint - sauce is too dry.

Pizza Review

richierigatoni11/23/23, 6:49 p.m.

6.9

Solid pizza no flop. Little crunchy for my liking. This place will always be L&Bs little brother.

Pizza Review

artie.mase5/26/23, 1:16 a.m.

7.7

Offensive lineman. Light on its feet. Good tasting sauce. Crust was perfect.

Pizza Review

pizzapro11024/11/23, 6:48 p.m.

6.4

Pizza Review

pizzablob7/7/22, 4:32 p.m.

7.7

The vodka Square was by far the best Of this bunch…it’s easily a 7.7- the upside down Sicilian 6.4 - I really didn’t care for the sauce at all. It’s too sweet and lacks flavor. The bake was nice though. The regular slice was a very basic 6.2. It’s decent but nothing to write home about.

Pizza Review

jason.forman1/20/22, 9:40 p.m.

7.9

Regular has an interesting tang to the sauce but nice crispy slice. The Brooklyn square is in the name and clearly lives up the hype.

Pizza Review

jay.marine11/16/21, 7:10 p.m.

7.8

For the first time, I’m not scoring the regular… when the place is called “Brooklyn Square Pizza” I feel they should get a pass. I liked it. Would definitely come back. Solid 7.8….

Pizza Review

sgt.pizza6/1/21, 5:48 p.m.

8.2

Regular: i didn't find it to be terrible. It obviously wasn't the best ive ever had. It was thin with a slight crispy to the bottom. I would consider it a soft slice, sauce is on the sweet side. 7.2 Square: crust is as close to spumoni as you could get. The sauce is not quite the same though. I feel this sauce is sweeter. All and all a real good slice. 8.2

Pizza Review

brian.roberts55/26/21, 6:43 p.m.

5.2

Sauce was really weird, grandma slice was awful like 3.1, regular just was just not good

Pizza Review

bowmansmash5/19/21, 8:39 p.m.

8.2

As close to L&B Spumoni Gardens as it gets without the trip and traffic to Brooklyn.

Pizza Review

buske2/12/21, 11:03 p.m.

8.8

Really good pizza.Love the sesame seeds and the pasta I would like a little sauce on it but I still love it ❤️❤️ Maddy

Pizza Review

jason.cataldi12/18/20, 8:10 p.m.

8.1

This is the reason you come here. Very “old world Brooklyn“ slice. Nice quality ingredients. Not too heavy.

david.dowling10/31/20, 11:12 p.m.

8.9

112 views•1 like

Pizza Review

conwayeric7/28/20, 8:34 p.m.

7.8

Don’t do the regular have to go with the square. Sauce is above average and crust is unreal.

Pizza Review

trump-of-pizza3/18/20, 9:35 p.m.

8.1

The Square is a solid 8.1 in the “Square” realm, I would just get the square. The regular is very disappointing- major flop, thin but no crunch whatsoever, very greasy..Regular is a 6.4

Pizza Review

cal9162/15/20, 5:54 p.m.

7.5

Pizza Review

billy.fryer2/15/20, 1:05 a.m.

6.4

It’s not L&B but it’s ok for LI pizza.

Pizza Review

cole_p2/10/20, 1:40 a.m.

7.0

A good slice, thin crispy crust with no flop. Not much flavor with the sauce, good cheese. Overall a good local slice. If your gonna go you have to get the square, it’s very good.

Pizza Review

jerry m.squillaro1/24/20, 7:13 p.m.

7.6

Pizza Review

anthony.desena1/22/20, 8:24 p.m.

5.0

I really wanted to like this pie but i was not very impressed. It was so soft it reminded me of a italian deli tomato pie. Not a ton of flavor. It also could have used a bit more cheese.

Pizza Review

mark.dellaragione10/24/19, 5:58 p.m.

7.8

Pizza Review

robert.detrano8/6/19, 7:15 p.m.

9.0

Was here for lunch had the regular slice and a vodka slice both had a good sauce to cheese ratio and were a little crispy no flip at all. Regular I give a 9 and Vodka I give a 10. Dave and Frankie have to go here.