Flimsy undercarriage and basic sauce. Average at best
cjaquilino1/6/23, 12:16 a.m.
Really light, airy crust, natural tomato tasting sauce, almost went back for a second slice, but was saving room for Romano's, which was unfortunate. Should've gotten another from here… Generally, I think Mario's is the best wood fired spot in Mahopac, but they're not a slice joint. I think this is where I'd go for New York style pizza. It's not gonna blow your socks off. But I felt it was a bit better than every other place here. Why? I felt the sauce and cheese where better balanced than the other spots and a tad more flavorful. It's nicely medium chunky with a good tomato flavor that was neither tart nor naturally sweet. It had a nice dark brown and black bake on the bottom and airy chew. The oven looked pretty old, something I forgot to also mention about Benevenuto's I. This is just abovr Dante's as my go-to plain slice Mahopac spot. Specialty slices looked solid too. I had a bite of that fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze slice. But I'd probably go to Benevenuto for them.
mr.mozzerella11/3/20, 7:39 p.m.
Server hot in 2-3 minutes with a little Lake Mahopac flop and a solid Westchester crisp. The sauce tastes like bland tomato flavored sugar water with chunks of raw tomato and no seasoning. There is maybe 15 - 20 strands of mozzarella on the entire slice and the quality is well below par. The dough recipe is plain and generic. This is a very poorly constructed slice with non of the components working together. Very, very sad pizza!
tb.carn7/9/19, 4:56 p.m.
No flop crunchy crust good quality toppings and a great atmosphere to enjoy it in.
tobeymaguire6/25/19, 5:51 p.m.
No flop. This is not football pizza - it’s thin and light. Crust was nice and crispy, parts of it mildly burned - but I like it like that! The cheese behaved and tasted perfectly and the sauce was good. No grease at this party! It all came together to deliver such an amazing pizza experience. Truly an authentic slice. Best I’ve had since I started reviewing slices on here.
pizza_slut5/9/19, 9:08 p.m.
Crust was just right.. nice and light, crunchy, no flop. Sauce is seasoned for a good slice.. prob would of gotten a better score if it was served hot
gregs01155/5/19, 4:58 p.m.
A little undercooked, despite that minimal flop. Cheese and sauce both pretty good
joeyv3/9/19, 10:44 p.m.
Good pie. Expect a sweet sauce and the crust a little under cooked . The pie has just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Not greasy or sloppy. Good pie . Very friendly service.
kgalvin289/30/18, 7:10 p.m.
Nice and saucy little under cooked but great flavor and a bit tooo doughy near the crust