Giorgio's Pizza

Came on a Saturday afternoon for my son’s AAU tourney. Tried a slice for $5. Very good taste and value. Liked the crisp and server made it extra crispy like I like it. It is very good but not quite on the level of Goodfellas (I gave it an 8). But this is still a very good option for a slice in downtown Indy.

Went here late night after a Pacer game. As an east coaster this is def not NY style pizza. It has the same size and purchase by the slice as NY but that's as far as it goes. Don't get me wrong it's a decent slice when you're drunk but outside of that I would pass.

Bit of a greaseball, solid crunch on the crust but little flavor with everything else.

Dave is spot on. Good pizza. Will come back. Good flavor. Little flop.

Something obviously happened since Dave’s review. I did not expect much from Indy pizza and they met my low expectations. The pizza was so undercooked…..i even offered a slice to one of the city’s homeless and they even turned it down.

A true New York style slice….would return when in town

Good pizza. Comparable to a good pie in central PA which is point of reference. Fine good pizza. Crust a little thick and chewy. Lite sauce and cheese. Staff is super friendly, fun place.

Kind of reminded me of Cosco or Sams club pizza. Didn’t taste bad. No crisp. But if this was the only option, I’d get it again.

Solid slice of pie

I had high expectations given the reviews but this has got to be one of the most disappointing pizzas I’ve ever had.

Cheese slice! This was a taste of New York no doubt about it. Cheese crust on point sauce could use work a little bland.

A bit floppy, thinner, but the crust has good taste.A little crisp, not a chewy crust. I liked the crust the best. Sauce isn’t overpowering, a bit light, could have used a little more to get a good taste in it. Fair amount of cheese, again not overpowering. Pretty decent pie overall.

For a slice place it was ok. Not very warm, but the staff was awesome!

So it's a basic slice. Thats it. The sauce is tangy and sweet but not overwhelming. The crust was crisp. Good undercarriage. It was solid but nothing that separates it from the pack or gets it in the upper echelons. I'll say a 7.2

Decent sauce but cheese needed some help. It's an okay football slice but super floppy

Underrated ‘Za in a great city, amazing sauce, dough, and cheese. You need to go to Giorgio’s!

Better than Goodfellas

A little garlic flavor which I can appreciate. Crispy and light dough. Toppings about average.

Definitely lacks in crisp. I think it’d be easily in the 7s with more crisp and a tad more sauce. It wasn’t dry by any means, just needed a little more. Pepperoni was good, almost reminded me of a jacks type pep. I will say the man behind the counter was a G and gave me a slice on the house. Good slice!

The pizza man was kind enough to cut my pizza slice in half so I could share it with another. This fits the NY slice because of the crunch! I only am wishing for a stronger cheese flavor - it’s a tad bland. Overall 6.6/10. That is all.