Lived up to expectation — tried stopping here a few times prior, but they were either on vacation or we had stopped on a Monday, as they’re closed Mondays.
Also ordered a mushroom/onion pie, and was just as good, if not, better, than the plain. Both pies, however were crispy, flavorful, and had great homemade sauce distribution.
One final note, if you’re in the area, there’s a place called SouzaFit just up the street. They have a smoothie called “Godzilla” that’s unquestionably a 9.3.
I live in Tuckahoe and will most certainly be back to Johnny’s.
