Johnny's Pizzeria

phenomenal

This place is legit. Amazing sauce. Cooked perfectly. Crunchy, thin, creamy texture to the cheese. Amazing pizza.

This was a tough one. The bite was high quality. The crust was a little over done and charred for my liking. This presented to much crisp and bitter flavor. The sauce and cheese bites were excellent. Had potential to be top 5. Make sure to order ahead or be prepared to wait. Great operation to watch though. True professionals. Cash only.

valid

The crisp is unreal, missing some flavor of the cheese but overall amazing!

Average at best.

I was expecting to be blown away after Dave’s 9.1 but honestly the sauce was very bland. The crust was very good and cooked well but the overall flavor just wasn’t there.

Great crisp, near zero flop. Maybe just a little more cheese but love the sauce on top of the cheese. Best slice I’ve had in the NYC metro area.

The best in NY (so far). Thin crust, good crunch and zero flop. Cooked Perfect. I recommend half regular and half hot peppers and sausage

Prez nailed the review. Super crispy. Awesome sauce. Not too cheesy but you dont mind. If an 8 is a drive worthy for your area. this is outta state drive pizza

Thin n Crispy

So good

Best pizza around!

Thin crust, good flavor. Great pie.

Pizza is fairly tasteless. Props given for consistency and execution. I simply think the dough is oily yet crunchy and the whole package is average.

#onebitereview9.2

If you like old school, traditional, thin & crispy pizza, this is the place to be! The sauce on their pies is absolutely sensational…it’s got tang & bang up the yin-yang! I’d travel over 3 hours just to smell this pizza! This might be the best pie outside of Brooklyn.

Fantastic pizza. Not quite has good as davey said but still great. Lady serving us was a bit rude but not letting that influence the score. Strong 8.3.