Best pizza I’ve ever had. Hands down.
j.baci7/29/21, 2:09 a.m.
Excellent pizza. I love the sauce on top. It’s impressive to me how well they do their crust using a normal gas oven. The thin, no flop crust, good sauce with light cheese all equals out almost perfectly. This 9.0 is well deserved.
christopher.aquilino7/18/21, 12:28 a.m.
The most cracker thin, crispiest crust I've ever eaten, from center to cornicione. It's charred *all* over the crust, not just at the bottom. And it's saucy throughout yet not heavy in saucy flavor, tangy, sweet, or herbal. The sauce is as light as the sauce in a small can of Red Pack tomato sauce. By the way, there's no much grease in sight, so it all holds together beautifully and is light in weight. l'd bet you could crush a whole pie by yourself. So why this score? I think you'll dock points if you’re a fan of cheesy slices. I'm not. But it is light on cheese. Same if you're not as big of a fan of the incredible crispiness. (I am). I also think the sauce isn't seasoned much, which is fine. But I think I like strong flavors in the sauce either in the sweetness (of San Marzano tomatoes), tanginess from garlic/acidic tomatoes, or from the herbal flavor of the oregano or basil.
daniel.digiacomo7/1/21, 3:20 p.m.
Mama knows Johnny’s makes the best pizza North of Manhattan. Don’t you disrespect Mama now.
joe.motta5/26/21, 6:25 p.m.
I had high hopes coming to this place. All reality first time having New York Pizza so this may be a bit biased, insanely good.
roda11475/26/21, 5:33 p.m.
Must try bucket list pie!!! Sauce A+ thin with zero flop the epitome of pizza!!!
pizzainmyface5/22/21, 8:20 p.m.
Highly recommend eating at the restaurant because of the thin crust. Sauce is tangy and a little sweet - very delicious. Crust was very thin, crispy, and a little charred. Wish it had a little more cheese but overall, this is a great pie.
royalpizzajourneys5/20/21, 5:35 p.m.
If you’re in the area and you like pizza, you would be an IDOIT not to stop in! Great fucking pizza
ricky_rigatoni5/19/21, 11:59 p.m.
At first I thought “damn that’s a lot of tomato” but the tomato was good, the crust crisp, and all in all fair play Johnny you make a good pizza
carter.gross5/17/21, 8:10 p.m.
Best pizza in westchester. Very crispy good flavor. Could have used a bit more sauce.
sgt.pizza5/13/21, 8:51 p.m.
Super thin dough. Sauce had amazing flavor. At first glance it looked to be to much sauce, however, it was an absolutely perfect ratio between sauce, cheese and dough. Almost not grease at all. Absolutely amazing pizza at this location.