cent1744/18/21, 11:29 p.m.
Excellent cheese, really really good sauce. The way it was cooked well done near perfect. Little bit more zing in the sauce I think I’d agree with Dave. I think I agree more with the app score. Ny suprema/sallys in new Haven slightly better IMO.
joseph.hager4/12/21, 9:29 p.m.
Killer pizza! Anytime im in NYC this is my go to spot. The meatballs are great too.
allrightsethy4/11/21, 10:41 p.m.
It was really good the sauce and cheese were the best.It was my favorite pizza of all time.
9 views•0 likes
bedstuypizzacritic4/8/21, 10:48 p.m.
Very good dough and toppings but I prefer neapolitan style pizza
fletcher.russell4/1/21, 11:43 p.m.
When you think of a pizza and your starving this is the kinda pizza that you picture 🤤
thephillypizzadude3/30/21, 9:10 p.m.
My 210 review and I was so excited for Johns. I was pretty disappointed they don’t sell slices and had to buy a medium for $21.00 and for that I have to deduct. I would have gave them a 9.3 on taste. It is a great tasting pizza soup to nuts it has everything as advertised but the cheese slide off my first slice didn’t like that. But it was right out of the oven so ..oh well
mike.wild3/28/21, 9:57 p.m.
Best two things about this pizza were the sauce and the crust. The sauce was perfectly sweet the way I like it. The crust was cooked pretty well done and had a tiny bit of char to it which made for a great blend of flavors. Pepperonis were also incredible on the slice I had. They had a nice crunch and were full of flavor.
fahles33/28/21, 8:20 p.m.
Tomato chunks were sweet. Not my style but very good. Personally enjoyed the pepperoni and ricotta half better.
max.trahan3/27/21, 10:33 p.m.
Sometimes words can’t describe why a pizzas an 8.5. John’s of bleecker street is an 8.5. The combination of the cheese and dough providing a lasting taste. The sauce or lack thereof limits the potential for the slice but still scores well.
rosey123453/26/21, 3:36 p.m.
This pizza is soooo so so good! The sauce is my favorite part!!! Get this pizza you won’t regret it! (3rd fav pizza in NY behind Joes at #1 and then John’s pizza of time square at #2)
navysteve3/23/21, 8:44 p.m.
This place lived up to the hype as I couldn’t wait to try once I arrived in NYC. Wish I could bring back the place with me to California
kgupta8223/22/21, 12:35 p.m.
Amazing pizza overall. The sauce was so flavorful and tasty. The crust had such a great taste and consistency. Top tier pizza