About Mellow Mushroom - Williamsburg
184 Yelp Reviews
ryan.raley4/12/22, 11:49 p.m.
Sweet crust. Not a ton of flop despite how thick. Both pies were traditional crust, instead of thin/crispy.
kaan.e12/11/21, 6:02 p.m.
Great White. White pizza. Not my favorite style of pizza but I thought it was pretty good. Flavorful and the crust had a nice crisp. I think the large 16” was like $27 and it fed three grown men.
tristen.ventura7/25/20, 10:28 p.m.
This pizza was rated a 7.1 when I came here and it definitely is not that good. I’m from New York so I didn’t have too high of standards coming here, but I will say it’s not bad. It’s not the place to come if you are looking for some really good pizza. It’s a good place to come with your family because of the cool atmosphere, friendly staff, and the nice village near by to hangout and explore. The pizza is super cheesy and the cheese is not that good. If it had a lot more sauce I think it would’ve been better a little. The crust is very thick, but it has a nice crunch and good taste to it.
nickwirk2/22/20, 12:52 a.m.
Heavy pizza. A little greasy and pretty doughy. Crust is delicious and very flavorful. Reminds me of a pizza you’d eat after a little league game.
stuart.hughes11/12/19, 3:03 p.m.
Great pizza highly customizable, you can have two specialty pizzas on a small. I always get some extra marinara on the side because the crust is da best! Don’t miss out on the beer cheese pretzel bites either. Good atmosphere, friendly staff.
pizzapresident6/8/19, 7:32 p.m.
Not bad pizza by any means but nothing to go crazy over. Good crust.
75 views•0 likes
michael.scrimgeour5/8/19, 5:05 p.m.
Might not be for everyone but Th he Maui Wowee is delicious....
wadezzeria4/26/19, 9:49 p.m.
Always a cool vibe in these places, BUT let’s focus on the pizza... super puffy crust and of course, tons of cheese... the sauce isnt great and the cheese, for how much there was, did not have a good chew to it... the bottom dough was about 3/4 in. Thick! The pizza was very sloppily made... the dough flavor is great... sweet and fun to chew... BUT... they pour a bunch of very pungent parmesan or other stinky italian cheese all over the crust and a pile in the center... while it provided the most actual flavor to the pizza, if asked, i would not opt for this addition... after trying this and one other location in the past, i’ve had my fill of mellow mushroom... cool restaurant vibe, but not for NY pizza connoisseurs
quinn.bellone3/23/19, 4:40 p.m.
Solid pizza. Can always count on Mellow Mushroom for a warm, full belly.