Nolita Pizza

Such a great slice. Very light but crispy and well balanced.

Decent slice; very NY; if in the area give them a try.

Eye test - ok Execution - decent Ratio - perfect Dough - super crunchy, no special taste Sauce - vanilla Cheese - standard Absolutely not travel worthy Quote of the day - nope

Not a bad slice quick in and out. Didn’t wait to long. Crispy with a good flavor. Decent price for a slice. Just really nothing that blew me outta the water but not bad.

Decent football pie/slice. A little soupy for me, could use some more crisp on the cheese. Enough flavor in the sauce where it's not bland. Its flavors come together okay. I wouldn't go out of my way for it. And I burned the roof of my mouth, so that's great.

Passed the flop test. Amazing sauce & amazing cheese.

Best pizza in NYC. Crust to sauce ratio is awesome. Way better than I expected. Amazing undercarriage.

Great flavor, good cheese, could be a touch crispier

Honestly a little disappointing given the overall rating. The sauce, cheese, and basil were all great. The crust was perhaps a bit too crunch and had no chew. A bit dense.

The regular slice was good, but the square one was incredible. I pass this place driving home from New Jersey and this may become a regular thing!

kinda salty

Needs more tomato sauce

M-m-m-m-mmmid. Not a good slice. The cheese was solid until you get to the crust and then it tastes bad. The fresh monz was one of the worst slices I’ve had in NY. At one point in the slice, the crust was nonexistent. No joke. In the middle of the slice - the thinnest level of crust you’ve ever seen. Not a good look. Not a good taste. Nothing good about it.

Slice was fantastic. Undercarriage was immaculate, great crunch. Ingredients were great with a great crust. If you aren’t a big cheese person it is a lot of cheese. I personally liked that it had a lot but my girlfriend preferred less cheese. One of the better slices I’ve had in NYC!

Crust was perfect amount of crunch without being burnt on the bottom. Very light with the right amount of cheese on top. No flop and just a little grease on the top.

Semi drunk review incoming. Ordered two only needed one, but this slice hit the spot. Not as crunchy as it should be which gets it docked a few, but interestingly enough the crust was like a 9.0. Worth it just for that. Real solid pizza spot amongst many great ones down here. Also awesome they are open late. Hard to find a better late night pizzeria in NYC.

We enjoyed. Great crispy, no flop crunch. We wanted a NY slice in Little Italy, and that’s what we got. Authentic. Nostalgic.

Everybody on here has lost their mind. This is an okay slice of pizza. I don’t know how you could give such a high score for a machine pressed dough. I visited Nolita Pizza at 4am on a Saturday, and it felt like I was in purgatory. Overall, good crisp and flavor, but seriously nothing to write home about. 7.1